3G and 4G – what a waste…

If you can read Urdu, read the text on the accompanying picture and imagine (in case you can’t read the text, even then imagine!) how would it be if same information is conveyed to the agriculturists using VIDEOS! And imagine if these videos could be seen on cellphone screens of the targeted growers of the targeted area, timed according to relevance and usefulness! Helping the growers and educating them about the latest methods of improving productivity in this manner has the potential of bringing an agricultural revolution in the country! This is the power of wireless broadband – like 3G and 4G!

The accompanying picture is a real-life example where an international donor agency, a provincial government and a cellphone service provider have teamed up to convey important information to peach growers, through SMS. But the text itself acts as a barrier because most farmers are unable to read. Even if they can read, Urdu is not understood in most rural areas. And even if the language is changed to the local one, any text is prone to misinterpretations.On the other hand conveying information with the help of short video clips helps bridge all these issues. Such potential benefits of broadband do not end with agriculture, rather these extend to all vital sectors – e-education, e-health, e-governance, e-commerce, and much more.

In developing countries the greatest impact that broadband makes is in semi-urban and rural areas – in areas where it is difficult to physically deliver pubic services and people have to travel to nearby big cities. Access to e-Services like e-Agriculture not only leads to economic uplift of citizens of those areas, rather it has several side-benefits too, for instance reduction in migration to large cities.

With the handing over of the long awaited licenses for 3G and 4G technologies, wireless broadband is now being rolled out in the country. The handing over of the licenses was a great occasion, although it would not have been such a big deal if the previous administration had not failed – thrice! But now that it has been done (credit to MoIT and PTA) we must remember that if we rest on our laurels, then we are surely wearing those at the wrong place! This is the time to start taking those next steps, so that the new technologies are not just used to download movies and Bollywood songs (although there is nothing wrong with doing that as well) but also to educate and make people more productive. The country as a whole should be able to reap the benefits of an inclusive growth.

Therefore what we require next are those videos that we just mentioned – the “Content” – dubbed in local languages. Such video-clips can be produced either with the help of real actors or with animations (just like those safety videos shown aboard the airliners now-a-days). Content that is meant for every sector of the economy. No doubt that there is a huge amount of very useful content available on the net, but there are several other issues with that. Firstly language would be an issue again, secondly rural folk will find it difficult to search in the vast ocean of internet, and finally (hopefully temporarily) the main source of such content, YouTube, stays blocked in Pakistan!

Sooner than most people think, smartphones are going to be the access devices. Big global players are already working hard to make the smartphones affordable, particularly for the large populations of developing economies. Google announced last month at it’s annual developers conference in San Francisco that it was working on a low-cost smartphone aimed at emerging markets as part of an initiative called ‘Android One’ (http://blogs.wsj.com/indiarealtime/2014/06/26/google-to-help-indian-companies-make-cheap-smartphones/). Earlier, Mozilla announced at the Mobile World Congress in Barcelona, that they will help develop a $25 smartphone, which will start selling by next year in India and Indonesia. According to a June 2014 report by Ericsson, globally smartphones accounted for around 65% of all mobile phones sold in first Quarter of 2014, compared to around 50% during same period last year (http://www.ericsson.com/res/docs/2014/ericsson-mobility-report-june-2014.pdf).

With the passage of time, cellphones will be used less and less for voice and more and more for data communications (it is already true in case of those of us who are active users of broadband via cellphones). Kids of the future will be amazed to know that the cellphones were originally created for voice! International Data Corporation (IDC) (http://www.idc.com/getdoc.jsp?containerId=prUS24314413). Worldwide report shows that already 1.5 times more smartphones are being sold than PCs + Laptops + Tablets combined since 2012. By 2017 this figure will be two-times. According to a Nokia study, in most of the world 30% of the cellphones are now smartphones, which is rapidly increasing. In Pakistan it is around 10%. But that should not be seen as low because in Pakistan we are only in the introductory phase of wireless broadband.

Thus all that spending on providing free laptops and tablets by the federal and provincial governments may be saved! Instead the efforts should focus on creating that all-important, urgently needed, local content, and making it available to the citizens in a way that they do not have to pay for it (already one-of-the-highest taxes on ICTs in the world, is causing enough harm). But unfortunately on the content front, there are no signs of any activity by the government. We, as a nation, are missing out on a unique opportunity to leapfrog and catch up with many of the developing economies who are galloping ahead riding the broadband wave – including our friends in Africa. When I got invited to the pan-Africa ICT4Ag conference in Rwanda late last year (http://www.piftikhar.com/2013/11/my-first-time-in-rwanda-and-ict4ag-conference/) I had the astonishing opportunity to see firsthand the deep and impactful use of ICTs in Agriculture in some of the African countries.

So here is what the federal and provincial governments need to do (with MoIT providing necessary guidance):

  1. Bringing the enormous experience related to Agriculture, Education and Health, etc. available in various ministries, and enormous experience of content creation available in the private sector together, and usefully employing all that to create wonderful content!
  2. Simultaneously using the funds available with USF, helping the telcos speed up roll-out of broadband in non-lucrative areas by investing in two infrastructure components: (a) Optic Fiber Cables to villages, to provide backhaul for wireless broadband, and (b) the last-mile access of wireless broadband for the villagers.

Unless the true potential of wireless broadband is understood, and steps taken to use it – just like several other developing countries are doing – the huge opportunity presented by 3G, 4G, etc. is going to be nothing but a terrible waste…


3G and 4G – what a waste…

10 thoughts on “3G and 4G – what a waste…”

  1. The points raised in your article emphasize the realities of our nation’s incapability to put a resource (including technology)to its best use (putting all politics asides). i believe there are very easy and viable solutions available to overcome the challenges that you have pointed out. There are already social enterprises that are on ground working with the farmers, what is needed is a bit of service designing in combination with the advent of cheap smart phones and 3G/4G capability. But there another flip side to this coin (with the fear of sounding a pessimist) which might be the biggest hurdle yet in the way of progress of such adventures and that is education or rather our resistance (imposed by the same class which is distributing laptops) to educate our working class, point being that once the education starts it won’t stop at farming and this might not sit very well with the ruling class . other than that forming social enterprises around telco have not proven very successful since Telcos are mainly Businesses, case in point being Bangladesh.
    interesting read, hope to read more of your thoughts soon.

    1. Thanks for your comments Faraz. You have raised some interesting points. Let me try to address those one-by-one:
      I am glad you agree that all that was being done by social entrepreneurs and others so far, should now be done using new technologies – for obvious advantages.
      I dont think that the rulers want to deliberately keep the nation uneducated. Indeed there are some who would like to, but they are a tiny minority. Problem is of wrong priorities and lack of knowledge/awareness of what the modern technology can do for them and the nation.
      And finally I am not advocating forming any social enterprises around telcos. In my proposal telcos’ job is to provide the necessary delivery service delivery vehicle, for which they get paid. Isn’t this the only thing that they do all the time?

  2. Excellent article. Same is noticed by many in industry that all Ministries needs to study respective industry verticals as well horizontal value chains … Hope these suggestions in article would also be part of comments on on-going policies review in planning commission and other functional Ministries. Good to have articles on 3G & 4G ,even after the much hyped auction time 🙂

    1. Thanks Fawad. You have hit the nail on the head. This is exactly the problem that I am struggling with – how to make these suggestions reach the RIGHT people? And I am saying this despite having access to the Minister level!
      As for still finding articles on 3G and 4G, well I honestly and sincerely feel what I have stated in the Blog – if these technologies are not put to right use, these would be absolute waste.

  3. A good thoughtful article. It is high time, that we start thinking and planning to make good use of 3G / 4G technology. Few things need to be done. (1) enabling environment at government level for good content development (2) introduction of low priced smart phones and (3) enhanced role of private and social communities/think tanks to create awareness, opportunities and solutions.

    Nadeem Syed

    1. Thanks Nadeem.
      To create enabling environment they just need to ask for these educational videos, services and applications – eg: defining what is needed and expressing their intent to buy those, or holding competitions. Many developers will come scrambling.
      Smartphones are getting cheaper faster than you can say the word Smartphone. But yes, we need to lower taxes and other barriers to entry.
      Creating awareness, is what I am trying to do… any help is most welcome!

Comments are closed.